Showing posts with label reading. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reading. Show all posts

Monday, May 7, 2007

Being Entertained by Sadness

I may have mentioned this before, but my friends and I have a “book club.” I use scare-quotes here because of two reasons: First, we don’t so much meet, as we discuss the books we read using Gmail and the like. Second, no one really seems to do it.

I think the second reason is the biggest problem this club is facing.

As it is, I’ve read every book that’s been proposed, and I’ve enjoyed some, and disliked others—but read them all. The latest book proposed (and I can almost guarantee the proposer, which for some reason isn’t a word to Microsoft, hasn’t read it) was Days and Nights of Love and War, by Eduardo Galeano. Before I get into my review of the book, I would like to point out this one thing:

The book was originally written in Spanish, and in my case, was translated by Judith Brister. I’ll explain why this is important in a minute (unless, of course, you know exactly why I claim it’s important, in which case: GET OUT OF MY HEAD!).

(I also just realized I wrote “I’ll get to this in a minute,” as if I can gauge typography in terms of time and not space, and not in the lovey-dovey, theory-of-relatively time/space, but clock-time and inches-space. Just another idiom gone awry, although this is specifically a disuse, as opposed to a misunderstanding).

So, Galeano. This book is both brutal and beautiful in its portrayal of the world that was (and perhaps still is?) Argentina and Uruguay in the Fifties, Sixties, and Seventies. Brutal, because these are not vacation-destination South America, including Buenos Aires. Repressive regimes meant secret police, a world of bribes, struggles just to eat, and arrests without cause. Galeano shows the ubiquity of murder, and the sense of weariness in his tone belies a sadness and acceptance, even while trying to run a magazine dedicated to resistance. Every time we meet someone new, it is only a matter of time before we find out that he or she is dead, and this repetition bears on the reader relentlessly, and yet isn’t completely numbing (which is a good thing).

Because you want the pain. When Adorno gave us the idea that there should be no poetry after the Holocaust, the idea is that any representation will never do justice to the pain and horror that was Auschwitz, so it would only belittle that moment by trying to replicate it. In other words, for people to watch Schindler’s List, and think: That was so real, are automatically re-situating the context of the Holocaust in thinking that the images and acting (although excellent), give us an accurate idea of what the Holocaust was like (I need to point out here that you should really check out the link I provide for Schindler’s List, because it kind of perfectly illustrates Adorno’s point—take note of the top of the screen on the web-site). Even when we know it’s not real, the perception of reality is such that we can come away from the movie with the belief that we can understand the Holocaust.

But at least people know about the Holocaust. Galeano is not writing from a position in which his situation is well-known. I’m not claiming it’s the same thing as the Holocaust, either, but then again, we may never know the numbers from these South American civil wars. And Galeano is doing his best to make sure that if we don’t know the statistics, at least we are aware of the “feel” of the time.

One way he does this is by setting up the book with the snapshot-stories. Each segment is short (at the most, a couple of pages), and the language moves from poetic to journalistic. In every case, a picture is drawn, and whether it is happiness or despair, it is fleeting. As the title implies, this is not a single moment, but a process, a turning of the Earth, and as such, the ethereal, picaresque nature of the vignettes bring us in and out of the times, places, and emotions.

And that’s why it’s so beautiful. Because Galeano, when he points out dinner with a friend, isn’t doing it to say what happened, but to let us know that he understands how important such encounters are. Especially because those friends could be dead any day (and often that is the case. Since he is writing this in hindsight, I can only imagine the ache he felt writing about these happy times, knowing that they can never happen again). It is also beautiful for its bravery, which is perhaps the reason why Galeano can “ignore” Adorno. He’s not writing after the oppressive times, he’s writing during. This isn’t history, this is blog.

But what does beauty mean, at least for me (and, I would contest, most of my four readers)? Because we are reading a translation, so how can I claim any motive or intention on the part of the author? Sure, Brister’s book is beautiful and sad, but is Galeano’s? Is it even the same story? Did he mean to be so poetic, or are these translational stylistic choices?

And, just as important, does it matter?

I’m not sure it does. Yes, on the one hand, I am analyzing a book with no true reference and little authority. But on the other, I am still a reader, and what I read made me feel these feelings and think these thoughts. It is therefore powerful nevertheless. Whether it is Galeano’s power or the power I’m attributing to Galeano, the fact remains that this is a book worth reading.

Now if only I could get my friends to agree that we’d all read the same book and then talk about it . . .

Saturday, May 5, 2007

It All Comes Together in the End. . .Kind of

I had my last class on Monday, and throughout the semester, I had been consistently messing up in interpretations of a particular literary critic/philosopher. Time after time, I would claim an understanding, and my professor would look at me, and then the class, and then in a tone that left no uncertainty as to how everyone should think, she would ask “What do you all think of David’s idea.” David’s idea. You don’t even need to read between the lines: by it being my idea, it is clearly not the idea of the philosopher (and therefore not the correct idea).

And yet, there’s a stubbornness innate in my being, and if anything, you could praise my “if at first you don’t succeed” attitude. But the idea with that sentiment is that eventually you will get it.

I didn’t get it.

And so in our final review class, I once again asked a question about the philosophy, but I did so by first positing “I think I understand what he means when he says . . . .” In a consistency the envy of your grandmother’s gravy, I had not understood, so once again the class had to endure an explanation of how I’m an idiot. Amazingly though, all that is just a preface to the actual problem.

Because, as I’m wont to do, once I did understand it, at least as far as my professor explained it, I then had to go ahead (and perhaps a little defensively, at least in tone), I asked: But who actually lives their lives like that?

I think I pissed her off. She then proceeded to explain exactly who lives this way: people who take her class. Apparently, one of the main issues she was trying to tackle with this course was the specific concept I simply wasn’t able to grasp. I would speculate that her anger and disappointment stemmed from two possible causes. First, because she didn’t do a good enough job teaching the subject, or at least delineating the goals of the course. While I would definitely contend this is partially a reason, I don’t think it was a big part, and therefore don’t think that was the pressing matter on her mind. The second reason, though, is that she can’t understand how someone in a graduate program can hear and read something at least three times, and not only not understand, but then act “offended” when he finally does.

In hindsight, I don’t think I’ll be requesting a letter of recommendation from her. It would be kind of hard to ask a question after I’ve already put my foot in my mouth.

Sadly enough, I told that whole story to get to idiom “foot in my mouth” (and seeing how I’m pretty tired, I wouldn’t be surprised if, in reading this, my use of the phrase doesn’t really make sense—but hey, it’s the Internet, so . . . whatever). But I really have a cultural point here; I’m not just trying to tell an anecdote about my life (because even I’m not that interested in my tale).

What caught my attention about “foot in my mouth” is that people say it a lot, but no one really thinks what it means. What does putting a foot in your mouth have to do with embarrassment, in a literal or figurative sense? I think I’d actually be pretty impressed if someone could put their foot in their mouth. In today’s world of Pilates, it may not be such a novel maneuver, but even if you could get your foot to your mouth, you’d need to dislocate you jaw like a boa constrictor to get it in there (unless, perhaps, you are a Chinese woman in an incredibly repressive household):


Snake Eating An Egg

This in turn led me to think about a discussion I had with my friend. We were walking home from another friend’s house, and my one friend, I’ll call him Esteban, was complaining about the snacks that our other friend, I’ll call him Tiberius, had provided. I (I’ll call myself “I”) said “you shouldn’t look a gift-horse in the mouth,” and he asked what that meant. After explaining what the proverb meant (yes, that’s the level of intellect I’m talking about with Esteban), he still wanted to know what it meant. I explained to him that one way a prospective horse-buyer would determine if a horse was in good condition was by examining the horse’s teeth. The idea was that if a horse’s teeth were healthy, then the owner had clearly taken care of the animal. Hence, “looking in its mouth” (disturbingly and yet not surprisingly, this was also done in determining the health of slaves). Therefore, for some reason, the horse-fairy leaves you a present under your pillow (and you haven’t refused an offer from Don Corleone), the idea is that you should be happy someone gave you a horse, and not worry if it’s healthy or not.

On the flipside, considering how expensive horses are (stabling, food, vet bills), this may be more like a curse than a blessing.

Horses tend to smell, too.

Regardless, the saying, like many proverbs and idioms that we use, are taken for granted. Perhaps ironically, it is this very idea, of reading “texts” for what’s on the surface, that was at issue for me with my professor. To end your suspense, the philosopher we were reading was Emmanuel Levinas, who was talking about . . . never mind. I doubt you want my interpretation of a philosopher I’ve already admitted to misinterpreting on multiple occasions. What’s important to know though, is that my professor’s point was that we have to approach reading in the same ethical style that Levinas proposes (okay, so I guess just ignore the previous sentence), where we can only know about ourselves in relation to the Other, and that is because the Other puts us into question. Now I’ll say I don’t really know what this means. But when reading a book (or any text), it’s not a good idea to go into it by thinking “I’m going to understand everything this book is going to tell me,” because that’s impossible. Books have infinite depth, but too often we care about plot and characters. While I personally see nothing wrong with that, because I think most books should be read to get what you want out of it, as a student, I concede the point. And, to be honest, it can make reading a much different activity than simply curling up in your chair and enjoying the story. Whether that’s a good thing or not is another question. But if you want to see reading in a Levinasian manner, take this exchange from Bull Durham:

“Crash” Davis: “You have to approach the game with fear and arrogance.”
“Nuke” LaLoosh: “Fear and ignorance. Got it.”

There are two things to note here. First, LaLoosh’s position is the one akin to Levinas’ because we should come to texts not thinking we know everything and be a little apprehensive about what that lack of knowledge means about us. It is also (and in my contention, rightly so), the position the movie is telling us is wrong – LaLoosh is misinterpreting the Wise Mentor (albeit to get a rise out of him).

Second, the movie is about baseball, and not about “texts.” But it’s a great movie anyway, perhaps one of the greatest sports movies ever, but overall one of the better movies period. It’s very funny, has a sense of depth beyond character and plot (so there), and loving embraces baseball. For one thing, it stars a Kevin Costner who isn’t pee-drinking douche. For another, it shows that although you may be insufferable liberals in person, such as the other two stars, Susan Sarandon and Tim Robbins, you can still be good actors, as opposed to, say, Sean Penn.

(I should note that part of my antipathy to Penn has to deal with the fact that I can’t really name any movies he’s been in, and the ones I can, I wasn’t impressed. My roommate swears by him, especially in 21 Grams, but even she couldn’t think of any other movies where Penn was good. I think maybe she’s thinking of Penn Jillette, which I could then understand. On the other hand, Robbins, if only for The Shawshank Redemption alone deserves praise, but he was also great in the aforementioned Bull Durham, had a great, smaller role in Arlington Road, was charming in Hudsucker Proxy (a highly underrated movie—check it out!), and of course was part of the classic Howard the Duck. In the case of Sarandon, it definitely doesn’t hurt that she’s very attractive—which is true of many insufferable liberals. Hell, if Ann Coulter was super-hot, I’m sure less people would call her a “Nazi-Devil-Bitch”—although that may just be my pet-name for her).

It’s also got the second best use of “Try a Little Tenderness” of any movie (although why they don’t use the Otis Redding version is unconscionable):



But mostly the movie’s great because it’s about baseball, and baseball is the greatest sport on the face of the Earth.

I know this may sound grandiose, but what other sport is both entertaining and poetry? Basketball is ballet with power, hockey is flying on ice, and football is war, but baseball. . .baseball is poetry. It is the greenest grass and the brightest sun. It is spring and summer and hot dogs and beer. The gliding outfielders, the slick infielders, the arc of a long fly ball to deep left. It is Yankee Stadium and history, it is Fenway’s Big Green Monster, it is Wrigley’s ivy.

It’s also a thinking mans’ game, in which the beauty of numbers comes to bear more than any other sport. Sabermetrics is the other piece of the poetic puzzle, because more than just a “game of inches,” it’s a game of statistics. The funny thing is, though, that too often, experts don’t even recognize this, hence the greatest sports blog of all time, Firejoemorgan.com. It is dedicated to being snarky to sports reporters who seem to get paid to know absolutely nothing about the sport they cover. How they can talk about “hustle” and “determination” and “clutch” as if these are quantitatively provable elements, and yet have no idea about why a pitcher’s win/loss record is says relatively nothing about how good that pitcher is (the reason, if you aren’t sure, is because wins are just as dependent on the team’s offense and defense as they are on the pitching performance. Case in point: Jason Marquis, of the St. Louis Cardinals, won 14 games last year, generally considered pretty good, but he had an ERA of over 6. That means for every one of those 14 wins, his team needed to score 7 runs. That’s a tall order for most baseball teams, which goes to show that all those wins were more because he was on a great offensive team and not because he was a great pitcher). How they can talk about how “good” David Eckstein is

Baseball is fantastic. If you don’t think so, listen to this and see if you don’t smile. And I don't really like the Mets (but at least I don't hate them like the Red Sox.

Which all goes to show you: Maybe if Levinas had taken some time to buy some peanuts and Cracker Jacks, he wouldn’t care so much about “defining himself.” Or maybe, the question he would be answering about himself is: Why can’t I be out there on the field, shagging flies?

And the answer? Because you don’t have the stats, Manny.

Probably won’t get an A in that class, though.

Thursday, November 30, 2006

Time to enter the crazy world of blogging

Hello world.

I'm David.

Now that we've been properly introduced, I figured I'd let you know what I plan to do with this here blogging page.

My hope is help everyone get a little perspective on the various texts I produce, read, and observe.

Now, for those unfamiliar with the broad literary-analsisy term "text", you're in for a real treat. Basically, a text is anything that conveys information, and this allows it to go beyond the simple book to encompass everything from movies, music, literature, and newspapers, to art, billboards, and even the internet itself. Granted, this is a simplistic view (and also, granted, it is the view I adhere to; it's not necessarily "truth"), but I think you'll understand what I mean as I post more. Mostly I'm going to write about books, movies, music, and television, but every so often I might delve into other arenas.

I also might start tempting fate, and posting my own "original" texts (the scare-quotes are to indicate how little self-esteem I have in this regard (and how much false modesty I therefore try to display)).

Who am I, and why should you care about my opinions? I'm no one. I just happen to consume a great quantity of texts, I like to talk, and I have the unfortunate stigma of "English Major" permanently attached to my being. As such, I tend to have a great deal to say about "stuff" and "things."

I'll start with my favorite book for my first installment.

Ender's Game by Orson Scott Card is a novel that I think all writers one day aspire to write. No, I don't think all writers want to write science fiction (although, deep down, I think a lot of them do, but can't, because it's actually very difficult (more on this later)), but I do think they want to write the complete, critically acclaimed book that becomes an instant classic and is beloved by children and adults alike.

Hyperbole? Perhaps. I do love this book, and I'd gladly fight a war of words on its behalf. But, with anything, you can take my word for it, or you can take the words of the text itself. Is it the greatest piece of writing ever? No, it's not. There are flaws. But unlike a lot of books, the flaws are not so glaring as to render the reader unable to function. Few and far between, everyone I've known who has read the book has never focused on them, but rather has sang its praises.

First off, it's a cool premise. Near future, war with aliens, children geniuses, school in space, zero-gravity laser tag. That in itself would probably make an enjoyable story, and, oh wait, it did. It's called "Ender's Game", and it's a short story. What makes the novel so incredible, at least for me, is that it goes beyond the mere glitz-factor of the Battle School, and plays up psychological, historical, political, and emotional aspects as well. Truth be told, the latter is the least emphasized of the listed aspects, and this is one of the "flaws" someone might find, but in the end, Card does a good job of giving us enough to establish that these are not just characters, they are human characters.

Honestly, I could go on and on about this book, but I'd prefer if everyone just read it. Then, write back to me what you think, and let me know if you would keep this book on your shelf or not. Before I figuratively go, though, let me take up the point I had made earlier about this book being for children and adults. I will say this until my face goes blue: Young Adult literature (YA) is the hardest thing to write in the world. Young people are picky, have short attention spans, and possess much smaller vocabularies while demanding much more explanation. Card has written a book that not only endears itself to children right away (with a cast of children, including the protagonist and most of the antagonists), but allows them to enter a complex, adult world without feeling condescended to. On the flip-side, adults have a book were the complexities are expanded with deeper readings and analysis, but isn't bogged down so that they miss out on the adventure and intrigue.

In case you're interested in learning more about Card, visit his web-site at http://www.hatrack.com/. To see what some other people think about Card (and not in a particularly gracious manner), check out this and some of its links (for the interest factor, if nothing else) http://www.kuro5hin.org/story/2005/5/28/22428/7034.

Until next time. . .